Spatial Models of Electoral and Ideological Evaluation in Latin-American Voters.

Main Article Content

Pablo Biderbost Moyano
Guillermo Boscán Carrasquero
Eduardo Munoz Suarez

Abstract

Starting from the idea that electorates are heterogeneous (Morris and Rabinowitz, 1997; Tomz and Van Houweling, 2008; Kropko, 2012), I verified the empirical performance of spatial models of electoral evaluation according to the ideological position of Latin American voters. Specifically, I used mixed formulations to evaluate the classical theory of proximity (Downs, 1957; Davis, Hinich and Ordeshook, 1970) and its alternative, the directional paradigm (Rabinowitz and Macdonald, 1989; Macdonald, Listhaug and Rabinowitz, 1991), in six presidential elections: Brazil 2006 and 2011, Mexico 2006, Chile 2009, Uruguay 2009 and Peru 2011. The results show that voters of the right follow a directional pattern while voters of the left behave according to the scheme of proximity. The data comes from Comparative Study of Electoral System (2023).

Article Details

Section

Investigación

How to Cite

Spatial Models of Electoral and Ideological Evaluation in Latin-American Voters. (2024). Encuentros. Revista De Ciencias Humanas, Teoría Social Y Pensamiento Crítico, 20 (enero-abril), 339-369. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10073752

References

Adams, James; Merrill, Samuel y Grofman, Bernard (2005). A unified theory of party competition: a cross-national analysis integrating spatial and behavioral factors. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Boscán, Guillermo (2016). Voto y competición electoral en América Latina [Tesis Doctoral, Universidad de Salamanca]. Gredos USAL. https://gredos.usal.es/bitstream/handle/10366/128562/DDPG_Bosc%E1nG_EleccionesAm%E9ricaLatina.pdf?sequence=1

Cho, Sungdai y Endersby, James W (2003). “Issues, the spatial theory of voting, and British general elections: A comparison of proximity and directional models”. Public Choice, 114(3-4): 275-293.

CSES. 2023. Module 3 Full Release [dataset] (Publication no. 10.7804/cses.module3.2013-03-27). from The Comparative Study of Electoral Systems (www.cses.org).

Davis, Otto. A; Hinich, Melvin. J. y Ordeshook, Peter. C. (1970). “An expository development of a mathematical model of the electoral process”. The American Political Science Review, 64 (2): 426-448.

Dow, Jay. K. (1998). “Directional and proximity models of voter choice in recent US presidential elections”. Public Choice, 96(3-4): 259-270.

Iversen, Torben (1994). “Political leadership and representation in West European democracies: A test of three models of voting”. American Journal of Political Science, 38(1): 45-74.

Kropko, Jonathan (2012). Who’s a Directional Voter and Who’sa Proximity Voter? An Application of Finite Mixture Modeling to Issue Voting in the 2008. American Presidential Election. http://www.polmeth.wustl.edu/media/Paper/manuscript.pdf.

Lewis, Jeffrey B. y King, Gary (1999). “No evidence on directional vs. proximity voting”. Political analysis, 8(1): 21-33.

Macdonald, Stuart. E. y Rabinowitz, George (1998). “Solving the paradox of nonconvergence: Valence, position, and direction in democratic politics”. Electoral Studies, 17(3): 281-300.

Macdonald, Stuart. E; Rabinowitz, George y Listhaug, Ola (1995). “Political sophistication and models of issue voting”. British Journal of Political Science, 25(04): 453-483.

Macdonald, Stuart. E., Rabinowitz, G. y Listhaug, Ola (1998). “On attempting to rehabilitate the proximity model: Sometimes the patient just can't be helped” The Journal of Politics, 60(03): 653-690.

Merrill, Samuel (1995). “Discriminating between the directional and proximity spatial models of electoral competition” Electoral Studies, 14(3): 273-287.

Merrill, Samuel y Grofman, Bernard (1997). “Directional and proximity models of voter utility and choice: A new synthesis and an illustrative test of competing models” Journal of Theoretical Politics, 9: 25-48.

Merrill, Samuel y Grofman, Bernard (1999). A unified theory of voting: Directional and proximity spatial models. Cambrigde: Cambridge University Press.

Morris, Irwin L. y Rabinowitz, George (1997). “Symposium. The Directional Theory of Issue Voting: IV On the Coexistence of Directional and Proximity Voters”. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 9(1): 75-88.

Rabinowitz, George y Macdonald, Satuart E (1989). “A directional theory of issue voting”. The American Political Science Review, 83(1): 93-121.

Stokes, Donald E (1963). “Spatial models of party competition”. The American Political Science Review, 57(2): 368-377.

Tomz, Michael y Van Houweling, Robert P (2008). “Candidate positioning and voter choice”. American Political Science Review, 102(03): 303-318.

Westholm, Anders (1997). “Distance versus direction: The illusory defeat of the proximity theory of electoral choice”. American Political Science Review, 91(4): 865-883.